Working with consulting firms is a time-honored practice for IT organizations. Consultants help companies identify best practices as well as organizational flaws, and IT leaders often ask consulting firms to compile competitive intelligence on rivals.
A lot of consulting firms’ work is writing reports with charts, and a few short years ago, that required mostly human labor. However, generative AI (GenAI) can now dramatically reduce the time and effort needed for business operations analysis and report and chart creation.
IT leaders must now be clear about exactly what they are paying consultants for, as the effect of AI on consulting billing is already evident. Tens or hundreds of billable hours spent on research, documentation and first drafts are harder to justify when AI can accomplish those tasks.
Still, consultants’ judgment, accountability and execution are still valuable.
"AI didn't make consulting cheaper," said Kevin M. Coles, fractional CIO/CTO for Coles Technical Group, an IT services and consulting firm located in Surprise, Ariz. "It exposed which part was never worth the price."
The consulting market as it stands
Like many other businesses, consulting is always changing in response to market dynamics.
"Five years ago, a lot of consulting value was packaged around access to expertise and the effort required to gather information, analyze it and develop recommendations," said Bret Greenstein, chief AI officer at West Monroe, a business consulting firm located in Chicago. "Those things still matter, but AI is changing their economics and raising the bar for clients to expect more action- and outcome-oriented help. [It’s] moving from knowing what to do to knowing how to do it and helping people do it."
AI has also affected staffing, though the message is somewhat mixed. For example, consulting company Accenture's SEC 2021 annual report listed its workforce as more than 624,000 people. This year, it had 814,000 employees at the end of August, according to its annual SEC report, but it also cut employees, as its fourth-quarter fiscal 2025 results included severance costs. The report wrote that Accenture was "exiting people in a compressed timeline where reskilling is not a viable path for the skills it needs."
The company’s fiscal 2026 report also says, "The rapid adoption of AI across our business requires continued large-scale reskilling and upskilling; if we cannot reskill and upskill our people at the pace and scale required … we have engaged, and may in the future engage, in actions … including reducing the rate of new hires and increasing involuntary terminations."
Firms have also renewed their focus on AI financially and seen increased revenue. Accenture reported new GenAI bookings of $5.9 billion for the 2025 fiscal year, while Deloitte's fiscal year 2025 announcement said it allocated over $3 billion to GenAI through fiscal year 2030. EY's fiscal year 2025 press release said AI-related revenue grew 30%.
IT consulting firm NPI Financial has seen AI offerings in the statements of work it reviews.
"Some of the largest consulting SOWs [statements of work] we've reviewed this year are AI build programs from Accenture, EY and Microsoft," said Jon Winsett, CEO of NPI Financial, located in Atlanta. "Clients still pay strategy firm premiums, but they're asking tougher questions about what that buys."
What AI may replace first
GenAI can carry out some of the more low-level tasks in consulting. For example, it can compose a routine analysis of operations.
"AI is giving internal teams the ability to handle more preliminary research and analysis, including vendor comparisons, RFP [request for proposal] drafts, IT assessments and initial recommendations," said Amit Venugopal, CIO of Thrive, an IT consulting firm located in Foxborough, Mass.
The tasks that used to fill junior consultants’ calendars, such as vendor landscapes and benchmarking, are among those AI is most likely to handle.
"That used to be weeks of junior consultant time billed at senior rates," Coles said. "AI does a credible first pass in an afternoon, and a good internal team can verify it."
Technical analysis is also a good fit for AI, according to Sachin Gupta, who works in enterprise AI and digital operating model transformation and serves on the advisory board at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs.
"Activities such as requirements analysis, process documentation, technical design comparisons, test-case preparation and initial code reviews are increasingly good candidates for internal teams supported by AI," Gupta said.
IT teams can also use AI for complex ERP transformation efforts that have historically consumed massive amounts of consulting hours, though AI may not completely replace humans for that particular use case.
For example, consultants gaining an understanding of differences in regional business processes for a global ERP transformation would have required reviewing hundreds of requirements, configurations and process documents in the past, Gupta said.
"AI can help internal teams identify inconsistencies, summarize differences and prepare an initial gap analysis," Gupta said. "That reduces reliance on consultants for preliminary analysis while allowing internal architects to retain ownership of the decisions."
What CIOs will still buy
While AI can perform some time-intensive activities previously done by consultants, CIOs will continue to procure consulting services. The execution of processes is one area where consultants’ expertise is still valuable.
"A CIO might use AI to compare cloud platforms or identify opportunities to consolidate vendors, but that doesn’t mean their team has the expertise or capacity to execute a migration, manage the required security and governance guardrails or understand the impact on the business," Venugopal said.
Buyers will still pay for consultants’ judgment, Coles said.
"In a negotiation, you pay for a firm’s market position, not its research," he said. "AI can tell you what a contract says. It can’t be accountable for what you sign."
Buyers are also willing to pay to have a human sign off on the work.
"Deloitte’s partial refund to the Australian government over AI errors in a report is a good reminder of why buyers still want a human signing off on the work," Winsett said.
The Australian Department of Employment and Workplace Relations republished Deloitte’s review with corrections in February 2026 after it was discovered that the report included various AI-generated mistakes, including a hallucinated quote. Deloitte Australia partially refunded the Australian government for the report.
"AI can process more information faster, but experienced advisors still need to challenge assumptions, navigate ambiguity, lead change management and own the quality of the recommendation," said Andrew Ray, chief innovation officer at Ensemble Health Partners, a business management consultancy located in Cincinnati.
The decision isn’t whether to avoid consulting firms but about using them for their actual expertise and the value they can offer. CIOs must decide whether the consultants’ knowledge that their company draws on is worth the consultants’ fee.
"We should pay external partners for differentiated expertise, independent judgment and measurable outcomes while using AI to strengthen the capabilities of our own teams," Gupta said.
How the business model may change
Given AI's capabilities, the traditional time-based business model for consulting services may change.
"As we are seeing across services, the focus will increasingly shift to selling outcomes versus selling an effort," said Aishwarya Singh, global head of Microsoft practice for cloud and agentic AI at NTT DATA, an IT consulting firm located in Tokyo. "This is a very fundamental shift in the business model, which was earlier based on people and time."
Additionally, buyers will want to know how the consultants use AI in their own work. And they should ask for specifics, Winsett said.
"Assume your consultants are using AI and make them show you how it's accounted for in the price," he said. "Ask for the mix of human and AI labor and the productivity assumption behind the fee."
A consultant’s savings from AI should benefit their clients, too.
"AI productivity should translate into better economics or better outcomes for the client, not simply higher margins for the consulting firm," Ray said.
Venugopal agreed.
"If a provider can complete an assessment in a fraction of the time, businesses should expect those efficiencies to translate into faster delivery, reduced costs or greater value," he said.
What CIOs should do now
CIOs should consider the following steps to ensure their company’s relationship with their consultant reflects current realities.
Audit repetitive spend. Analyze the hours a consultant spends compiling data and sharing choices.
"Rather than paying consultants to gather information or present options, businesses can increasingly handle that groundwork themselves and engage outside experts to evaluate tradeoffs, drive industry-specific benchmarks and operating models to make decisions and execute," Venugopal said.
Buy decisions, not documents. IT leaders and consultants should define the required outcomes of an engagement before signing the contract.
"Before signing, write down the one decision the engagement has to produce and judge the return by that," Coles said.
Do not skip the assessment. AI can speed up analysis, but organizations should still study how their operations work today. CIOs should counterbalance the efficiency gains from AI with an expanded scope and investment in assessments such as deep process observation and objective analytics to achieve a complete and accurate understanding of the company’s current state, Ray said.
Rewrite the contract. CIOs should document any time savings from AI.
"When a firm pitches AI accelerators, write the effort or timeline reduction into the SOW," Winsett said.
Protect the data. Protection of confidential information has always been part of consulting contracts. An AI-era contract should explicitly state how the consulting firm will use the company's data.
"CIOs should expect transparency about where and how consulting partners use AI, especially when enterprise data, proprietary information or critical technology decisions are involved," Gupta said.
Winsett agreed.
"We're seeing services contracts that give the firm blanket consent to put client data into its AI tools," Winsett said.
Include consultant phase-out from the beginning. CIOs should incorporate a knowledge handover into the deal on day one.
"Make capability transfer part of the deliverable," Greenstein said. "Have your people work alongside the consulting team."
The reality is that AI is here, consulting firms are using it and CIOs need to come to terms with that fact.
"Ultimately, the question is no longer whether a consulting firm uses AI but whether it’s delivering better outcomes for customers," Venugopal said.
Sean Michael Kerner is an IT consultant, technology enthusiast and tinkerer. He has pulled Token Ring, configured NetWare and been known to compile his own Linux kernel. He consults with industry and media organizations on technology issues.