In the wake of a Black October, followed by a punishing spate of tech outages in November, the need for competent, skilled cybersecurity professionals has never been more evident.
AI offers cybersecurity professionals the opportunity to do more than ever, taking on tasks that once occupied hours. From triaging security alerts and analyzing logs to identifying vulnerabilities and generating reports, AI tools are increasingly handling the repetitive, operational work that has traditionally provided an entry point into the profession.
That shift raises an important question: If AI does more of the basic cybersecurity work, will the next generation of professionals lose the foundational experience needed to become skilled security practitioners?
There are legitimate reasons for concern. Entry-level security analysts have historically learned their craft by investigating alerts, recognizing suspicious activity and gradually developing an instinct for distinguishing genuine threats from false positives. As AI assumes much of that work, emerging professionals could miss valuable opportunities to build those instincts.
The counterargument is that rather than eroding skills, AI is changing what cybersecurity professionals need to know, how they approach problems and where they apply their judgment. The industry faces a dual challenge: preserving the foundational knowledge that makes effective security professionals while preparing a workforce capable of directing, evaluating and challenging increasingly sophisticated AI systems.
According to ISC2's July 2026 research into AI's impact on cybersecurity roles, 56% of the cybersecurity professionals surveyed said AI had somewhat or significantly reduced the need for entry-level positions over the previous year. At the same time, 53% believed AI was creating new types of entry-level roles.
TechTarget spoke with security experts to get their thoughts on what the future of cybersecurity looks like for practitioners as AI emerges as both the greatest threat to enterprise security and the most helpful tool available to them.
New instincts for the AI era
Working with AI requires a different kind of expertise. Cybersecurity professionals must know not only how to investigate threats but also how to assess the reliability of the tools helping them do so.
ISC2's report found that 65% of cybersecurity professionals surveyed had spent significant time deciding whether to trust or act on AI-generated recommendations. Another 63% reported spending time reviewing and validating AI outputs. The findings point to an emerging skill set centered on critical thinking, verification and judgment.
Casey Waughn, senior associate for data innovation, security and privacy at national law firm Armstrong Teasdale, sees AI changing the way analysts build security instincts but as incapable of filling in for human beings.
“AI tools don't remove the need for judgment. They move it to a different place,” she said. “Someone still has to decide whether the tool flagged the right activity, whether it missed something, and whether its analysis actually holds up. That takes the same pattern recognition and root-cause thinking earlier analysts developed by reading logs by hand.”
Training for what’s next
If AI changes how analysts work, it’s only logical that training for those roles would evolve.
“One thing we’re very focused on across all our agencies is how we maintain human skills and allow humans to do tasks which could be completely automated,” shared CEO Richard Horne of the UK National Cyber Security Centre. “We actually need to be able to develop [analysts] to have the judgment that we need to be able to oversee AI effectively.”
For years, cybersecurity career paths involved learning through repetition. Junior analysts reviewed logs, investigated alerts, documented incidents and escalated suspicious activity. Over time, exposure to these tasks helped them recognize patterns, understand attacker behavior and make increasingly sophisticated decisions. AI threatens to disrupt that development process.
Training programs will need to adapt accordingly. Rather than simply teaching professionals how to perform tasks that AI can increasingly automate, cybersecurity education must teach them how to understand the underlying processes, evaluate AI-generated findings and independently determine whether recommended actions make sense.
“I wouldn't preserve a manual process simply because that's how previous generations learned,” said Kory Daniels, chief security and trust officer at managed security service provider LevelBlue. “The bigger question is whether analysts understand what's happening underneath the technology well enough to recognize when something doesn't look right. Training should give people that foundation, while putting even more emphasis on problem-solving, curiosity and adaptability.”
Organizations will need to rethink how they develop junior talent. Hands-on laboratories, simulated incidents, mentorship and supervised investigations can provide opportunities to practice foundational skills even when AI handles routine production work.
Experts recommend bolstering several capabilities in new cybersecurity talent:
-
AI literacy. Understanding how AI systems work, their limitations and the circumstances in which they are likely to make mistakes.
-
Critical thinking. Challenging AI-generated conclusions, recognizing inconsistencies and independently validating findings.
-
Contextual judgment. Understanding an organization's infrastructure, business priorities and risk tolerance when evaluating AI recommendations.
-
AI oversight. Knowing how to direct AI agents, establish appropriate boundaries and monitor their actions.
-
Communication. Explaining technical findings and security decisions to colleagues, executives and other stakeholders.
Changing how the work gets done
The cybersecurity industry isn't experiencing its first major technological transition. Automation, cloud computing, virtualization and advances in security analytics have all changed how professionals perform their jobs. Each development has shifted the skills organizations need and altered the balance between manual work and higher-level decision-making.
AI is likely to follow a similar trajectory, although its ability to perform increasingly complex tasks leaves a great deal of room for uncertainty. The danger is assuming that automating work automatically eliminates the need for the people who once performed it. In cybersecurity, that assumption could create a significant workforce development problem, undermining the pipeline of experienced professionals needed in a relentless threat landscape.
“Some skill prioritizations are going to adjust as AI changes how cybersecurity work gets done, Daniels said. “That's happened every time this industry has gone through a major technology shift. I'm less worried about someone losing a specific manual skill than I am about people losing the ability to think critically, solve unfamiliar problems and learn quickly. If we keep developing those capabilities, AI can raise the ceiling for security teams without hollowing out the talent underneath them.”
ISC2's 2025 Cybersecurity Workforce Study supports Daniels’ assertion, finding that 73% of respondents believed AI would create demand for more specialized cybersecurity skills, while 72% anticipated a greater need for strategic mindsets.
“Analysts entering the field alongside AI will build their instincts differently than people who started 20 years ago, and that’s a natural part of an industry that never stops evolving,” he added. “What matters is whether they’re learning how to think critically, ask the right questions and adapt when the tools and threats inevitably change.”
Richard Livingston is an editor for TechTarget Cybersecurity, covering news, trends and analysis. Livingston's professional background includes editorial positions in the national defense industry covering the U.S. Army Medical Department, as well as offensive and defensive cyberstrategy for military and government audiences.