Organizations today achieve enterprise-wide networking with two distinct technologies: SD-WAN and multiprotocol label switching. While both approaches remain widely used, network technology professionals might prefer the ROI the organization can achieve with SD-WAN.
SD-WAN uses specialized software to dynamically route network traffic based on business requirements and available network resources. Multiprotocol label switching (MPLS) is a legacy networking technology developed by major network carriers in the 1990s. It uses dedicated transport circuits to route data packets using predefined paths.
SD-WAN uses a variety of network technologies, while MPLS uses established carrier-based connectivity. From an ROI perspective, SD-WAN offers several benefits over MPLS, including the following:
- Reduced costs by eliminating hardware associated with MPLS.
- Security improvements at enterprise and branch levels.
- Improvements in network management.
- Application performance improvements and enhanced uptime.
- Better expense management by intelligently using multiple network technologies.
How to determine SD-WAN ROI
The following provides a basic framework for calculating SD-WAN ROI when migrating from MPLS:
- Identify existing MPLS costs to determine the baseline expenses. This can include circuits, hardware, support and maintenance. Factor in the time and assets required to manage network troubleshooting and provisioning.
- Estimate SD-WAN costs. These should include the SD-WAN subscription and/or licensing fees, training and implementation expenses, and continued managed service costs from the SD-WAN vendor.
- Examine potential savings. IT leaders should estimate savings based on network connectivity costs, a reduction in physical devices such as routers and switches, and how these changes will impact support hours for troubleshooting and manual configuration.
- Track efficiency metrics and KPIs. Metrics such as mean time to resolution, network uptime percentage, application performance improvements and user satisfaction scores can provide insight into how changes have directly affected performance after moving to SD-WAN.
- Calculate payback period. This is the time that organizations need for cumulative savings to exceed the initial investment.
SD-WAN ROI compared with MPLS
Quantifying the ROI for SD-WAN versus MPLS is largely based on assessing cost savings and operational efficiency.
To compare ROI between SD-WAN and MPLS, IT leaders can use the following formula:
- ROI (%) = SD-WAN investment cost savings (versus MPLS) + operational gains (versus MPLS) – SD-WAN investment×100
SD-WAN investments include hardware and software costs, as well as deployment and training expenses.
Organizations can also calculate SD-WAN cost savings and operational gains. This is the total of lowered connectivity costs, hardware costs, enhanced security using SASE, reduced IT personnel costs, enhancements in productivity and increased efficiency.
Two key factors that elevate SD-WAN over MPLS are expense reduction and improved operational efficiency.
Expense reduction
SD-WAN enables enterprise network managers to use cost-effective broadband and wireless connectivity in lieu of costly MPLS circuits. This can result in 20% to 50% savings based on traffic and the organization's network architecture.
By nature, SD-WAN consolidates networking and security functions, as well as reduces enterprise dependency on on-site hardware. This can translate into CapEx savings.
In addition, centralized monitoring and cloud-based management of network functions can mitigate the need for IT and networking staff travel and facility configuration costs.
Improved operational efficiency
With SD-WAN, centralized management dashboards can facilitate faster service configuration and facility deployment. This can reduce operational costs by 30% to 40%. The advanced traffic routing and AI-driven analytics provided by SD-WAN can also increase performance and reliability over MPLS systems.
SD-WAN can also dynamically scale resources, and its use of cloud-based resources can speed up integration of new locations and enhance digital transformation.
Paul Kirvan, FBCI, CISA, is an independent consultant and technical writer with more than 35 years of experience in business continuity, disaster recovery, resilience, cybersecurity, GRC, telecom and technical writing.